Archive for bible

Endigar 1116 ~ Psychic Change vs. Psychic Chains

Posted in Uncategorized with tags , , , , , , , , , , , on November 10, 2026 by endigar

Someone in this morning’s recovery meeting brought up that their sponsor has his sponsees to read 2 Corinthians 10:5. Initially, I could see how this might go with several Big Book passages that deal with having a psychic change with psychic being an older definition of the word. The Doctor’s Opinion talks about the displacement of old ways of thinking that are replaced with newer ways. A moral psychology. There is also mention of smashing lurking notions of being normal when it comes to alcohol. There is also a reading about How It Works, talking about letting go of old ideas or our results will be nil. There is a discussion in Bill’s Story about Rowland Hazard going to see Carl Jung a second time and he discussed the spiritual experience that produces a displacement of old ideas, a psychic change. But the Scripture cited also has the historical baggage of Paul trying to defend the legitimacy of his Apostolic calling from challenges within the Corinthian church. As such, it could be interpreted as a silencing of a questioning mind for the sake of social cohesion. And I find that possibility rather repugnant.

COMMENTARY FROM AI:

I think you’ve identified a genuine tension between two very different kinds of transformation: the liberation of the mind from destructive patterns of thinking, and the subjugation of the mind to an external authority. Both can be supported by a particular reading of 2 Corinthians 10:5, but they are not remotely the same thing.

And I believe the historical context you’ve raised deserves considerable attention.

1. The connection with the Big Book

Your initial association is well founded. There are several passages that fit the psychological interpretation of Paul’s language.

Big Book referenceConnection
The Doctor’s Opinion, p. xxixDr. Silkworth describes the necessity of an entire psychic change.
There Is a Solution, pp. 26–28Rowland Hazard’s encounter with Carl Jung introduces the possibility of a profound spiritual transformation.
More About Alcoholism, p. 30The alcoholic must abandon the delusion of being able to drink like other people.
How It Works, p. 58Holding on to old ideas can prevent recovery.

The older use of psychic concerns the psyche—mind, soul, and inner life—not paranormal abilities.

One important refinement: the particularly striking description of old ideas, emotions, and attitudes being displaced by new conceptions appears in There Is a Solution, page 27, in connection with Jung’s explanation.

These passages describe a fundamental reorganization of how someone understands themselves and their relationship with reality.

Alcoholics Anonymous+2

But notice something important: AA is not asking an alcoholic to surrender the faculty of thinking. It is asking that person to reconsider beliefs that have proved destructive.

That is an epistemological distinction.

2. What Paul was actually confronting

In 2 Corinthians 10:3–6, Paul employs military imagery. His spiritual weapons demolish fortresses, overthrow arguments, and take thoughts captive to obedience to Christ.

The Greek is revealing:

  • Logismous refers to arguments, reasoning, or calculations.
  • Noēma refers to a thought, conception, or mental design.
  • Aichmalōtizontes means taking captive, using the language of military conquest.

This is strong language. It is not simply a first-century recommendation to practice constructive thinking.

Bible Hub+1

You are also correct about the immediate context.

Paul is defending his apostolic legitimacy against critics within the Corinthian community. His authority, his conduct, and even his personal presentation have come under attack.

And then comes verse 6: We are also ready to punish every act of disobedience, whenever your obedience is complete.

That considerably changes the atmosphere of verse 5.

Paul is not merely describing a private struggle with destructive thoughts. He is addressing a community in conflict over religious leadership and doctrinal authority.

To be fair to Paul, he insists in verse 8 that his authority exists to build up the Corinthians, not destroy them. His stated standard of obedience is Christ, not simply his personal preferences.

Nevertheless, the difficulty remains: who gets to determine which thoughts oppose the knowledge of God?

If an apostolic leader claims exclusive authority to answer that question, the difference between spiritual formation and intellectual control becomes dangerously narrow.

3. Paul also defended discernment

There is another side of Pauline thought that makes your concern particularly interesting.

In 1 Thessalonians 5:21, Paul instructs believers to:

Test all things; hold fast what is good.

And in 2 Corinthians 13:5, he tells his readers to examine and test themselves.

These instructions do not amount to unlimited freedom of theological disagreement. Paul clearly has doctrinal boundaries.

But neither does his writing consistently reject examination or reasoning.

There is a productive tension between the Paul who commands believers to test things and the Paul who announces the captivity of every thought.

Perhaps that tension is partly between the ideal of individual spiritual discernment and the practical demands of maintaining a religious community.

4. The danger within sponsorship

This is where your observation becomes especially relevant to recovery.

Imagine two sponsors using 2 Corinthians 10:5.

One says:

“When your mind tells you that you can safely drink again, examine that thought. Is it supported by your experience, or is it the old delusion returning?”

Another says:

“Your objections are evidence of rebellious thinking. You must bring those thoughts into obedience rather than question what I am teaching you.”

The first encourages discernment.

The second can encourage dependency and intellectual submission.

Interestingly, AA’s Second Tradition establishes an important safeguard:

Our leaders are but trusted servants; they do not govern.

It places authority in the group conscience rather than in the unquestioned commands of an individual.

That seems to me an essential distinction when applying scriptural language within a sponsorship relationship.

5. A transformation of consciousness, not its imprisonment

I would frame the difference this way:

A genuine psychic change liberates a person from the tyranny of an old idea. An authoritarian conversion merely replaces one tyranny with another.

A person who once believed alcohol was necessary for survival may discover that this belief is false.

That discovery frees the person.

But if that person subsequently believes every thought must receive approval from a sponsor, preacher, or spiritual superior, the mechanism of dependency may simply have acquired a new object.

There is a further irony here. A person who is prohibited from questioning their convictions cannot meaningfully examine whether those convictions are true.

And without examination, how does one distinguish spiritual growth from indoctrination?

What I find especially interesting about your reaction is that you did not reject the passage when you first heard it. You immediately recognized its potential value within recovery. Your objection arose when you restored the historical context and noticed how the same words could serve the preservation of institutional authority.

That is not an argument against psychic change. It is an argument for examining the authority under which that change occurs.

I would leave you with a question that reaches beyond Paul and into the philosophy of the Twelve Steps:

When we surrender our will, are we surrendering the illusion that we control reality, or are we surrendering our responsibility to think, question, and exercise moral judgment?

Those two forms of surrender can look remarkably similar from the outside. Yet I would argue that they lead to profoundly different kinds of spiritual life.

Endigar 1099

Posted in Uncategorized with tags , , , , , , , , , , , , on December 30, 2025 by endigar

From Courage to Change of Nov 16:

For a long time I tried to let go and let God, but I couldn’t seem to do it. I needed to find a concrete way to let go. I heard someone share at a meeting that she pictured her loved ones on a beautiful ocean beach, basking in the light of a Higher Power.

Al-Anon has taught me to take what I like and leave the rest. I couldn’t relate to the beach scene, but I did find comfort in the general idea. Once again, the experience, strength, and hope of another Al-Anon member led me to find my own, personalized answer. I now envision wrapping my loved ones in the kind of blanket that I think they’d like – a down comforter, an army blanket, a patchwork quilt – and gently handing them to my Higher Power. I find it important to be very specific. After all, my fears and worries are specific.

With a clear picture of my loved ones in my Higher Power’s care, I am much more able truly to let go and let God.

Today’s Reminder

When I’m anxious about other people, I need my Higher Power’s help. Fighting with fear often strengthens its hold over me, but turning my loved ones over to God can free us all.

“‘Let Go and Let God’…teaches us to release problems that trouble and confuse us because we are not able to solve them by ourselves.” ~ This Is Al-Anon

END OF QUOTE—————————————

Many of the spiritual mantras in my life have sounded good and even powerful, yet failed to work for me in practice. “Perfect love drives out fear.” I held onto that phrase not because it changed me, but because it seemed to gesture toward a mystery worth exploring.

The same was true of a recovery saying meant to ease anxiety: “Let go and let God.” Again, I kept it more for its meditative challenge than for any proven effectiveness in the combustible, oxygen-rich atmosphere of everyday life. I have often asked, when faced with spiritual assertions: Where is the meat hook? How do I move from euphoric fog to practical application?

The Twelve Steps of Recovery begin with a grounded commitment to truthfulness—honesty. I didn’t reject these sayings. Instead, I assumed the problem might be my inability to align with the reality they pointed toward. Still, I need a meat hook to accompany any spiritual proclamation. Without one, I’m left with self-condemnation that quickly hardens into animal frustration. So I hold the mantra lightly and listen for the meat hooks to emerge within the collective wisdom of recovery.

Over time, some of that fog began to take form:

  1. Let go of outcomes. Take responsibility only for the next right thing.
  2. When worried about others, become a lighthouse. Build a life worth emulating.
  3. Let go of God’s relationship with those I love. Grant them the dignity and freedom of their own journey.
  4. Offer yourself to their God as available help, then remain open and attentive.
  5. Practice peace and value intelligence over panic. This creates room for the serenity, courage, and wisdom that a petitioned God provides.
  6. My God does not desire loneliness, but a family of children who delight in the presence of their source parent. I release the orphaned posture and watch the unseen become tangible.
  7. Perhaps perfected love really can drive out fear— once it finds a way to land in lived experience.

Endigar 1058

Posted in Uncategorized with tags , , , , , , , , , , , , , on October 10, 2025 by endigar

From Courage to Change of Oct 9:

I used to think of God as my adversary. We were engaged in a battle of wills, and I wasn’t about to let down my guard. You can imagine how quickly this attitude led me to hit a hard emotional bottom! I came to Al-Anon, but I was reluctant to admit that I was powerless. I knew it was true — I had obviously failed to conquer alcoholism — but I wasn’t going to submit to my enemy!

I’m so grateful to Al-Anon for helping me learn to surrender. It took a long time, but I finally realized that surrender does not mean submission — it means I’m willing to stop fighting reality, to stop trying to do God’s part, and to do my own.
When I gather flowers, or marvel at nature’s wonders, I do not lose face when I concede that I am not in control. So it is with everything in my life. The best way I’ve found to invite serenity is to recognize that the world is in good hands.

Today’s Reminder

Today I can be grateful that the earth will continue to revolve without any help from me. I am free to live my own life, safe in the knowledge that a Higher Power is taking care of the world, my loved ones, and myself.

“The First Step prepares us for a new life, which we can achieve only by letting go of what we cannot control, and by undertaking, one day at a time, the monumental task of setting our world in order through a change in our own thinking.” ~ One Day at a Time in Al-Anon

END OF QUOTE—————————————

I was at a block this morning. I truly did come into the recovery rooms with a high level of distrust for surrender to any concept of God, a Higher Power. It has gotten much better, but internal cognitive dissonance prevents me from settling into the stable trust I desire. Sometimes, I am just tired of the limitations of my life. And I did not want to project that struggle into today’s writing. I asked AI to help me out and what it produced I found to be beneficial. I hope that it will be for you as well:

Opening Context

Many of us arrive in recovery with clenched fists toward the idea of God. We confuse control with strength and surrender with defeat. In truth, the First Step dismantles that illusion gently: powerlessness is not humiliation but permission to rest. To stop trying to play God is not to lose our dignity, but to rediscover it.

When the author says they once saw God as an adversary, they are describing one of the most human reflexes — the fear of being overpowered. Yet the paradox of recovery is that what feels like yielding to an enemy becomes yielding to life itself.


Scriptural Echoes

  • “Be still, and know that I am God.” — Psalm 46:10
    Stillness is the first act of trust.
  • “Come to me, all you who are weary and burdened, and I will give you rest.” — Matthew 11:28
    The rest offered here is not absence of effort but the end of unnecessary struggle.
  • “Thy will be done.” — The Serenity Prayer’s hidden anchor.

Spiritual Realization

Surrender transforms when it ceases to be a white flag and becomes a flower gathered. The same hands that once clenched in defense now open to gather beauty. The text’s shift from “battle of wills” to “gathering flowers” is not accidental — it is a description of inner evolution.
Surrender, rightly understood, is the release of illusion: the illusion that our will can rewrite gravity, time, or the hearts of others.
Reality becomes a teacher instead of an opponent.


Meditative Questions

  1. Where in my life am I still treating reality as an adversary?
  2. What does it feel like in my body when I release control — not in despair, but in trust?
  3. Can I remember a moment when I stopped fighting and something good quietly unfolded on its own?
  4. How might I honor my Higher Power today not through effort, but through allowing?

Closing Reflection

The world continues to turn without our command, yet this is not a reason for despair — it is the foundation of serenity.
The First Step is not an abdication of power, but the discovery of where true power lives: in humility, trust, and alignment with the rhythm that already carries us.
When we stop trying to make the sun rise, we finally notice the dawn.

Endigar 989 ~ A Step 3 Exercise

Posted in Uncategorized with tags , , , , , , , , , , , , on June 26, 2025 by endigar

I have performed an exercise that I have my sponsees in AA do, if they have some connection with a Higher Power that they wish to bring forward into the recovery process:

On a sheet of paper, divide in two and write out what you like about your Higher Power. On the other side, write out questions that disturb you and invokes anxious curiosity about your HP.  These are the things that I like about my HP:

  1. HP appears to care about us and is involved with us individually.
  2. HP appears to take Self-limiting measures to insure our free will.
  3. I like the sacredness of stories that seems to have been passed on.
  4. I love the storied masks I can put on my attempts at interaction with the HP.
  5. I love the sense of mission that comes from connection with my HP, however tenuous.
  6. I love my children and my intimate relationships that seem to have been facilitated by my HP.
  7. I love that my HP gave me a good dose of my mother’s creativity and my father’s dedication to protection.
  8. My God heard Me in repairing damage I have done with those I loved deeply.

These are the lingering questions that are disturbing to me:

  1. What does it take to overcome limitations in our personal communications with one another?
  2. Why death and aging and disease? Is there a promised resurrection while still in the body that I read about in Philippians all those years ago?
  3. Will I ever be alright with life on life’s terms? Why want You help me? And help Me remember? Why do I so often find myself standing at the precipice of suicide?
  4. How are we to navigate sexuality and procreation while also facing our shadow selves? Why is spiritual development tied so strongly to gender trust? This is a lot for humanity to take on with insufficient information.
  5. Why the chaos storm that swept away my marriage covenant and my white knuckled sobriety of 14 years? Why the death of my preborn infant in Germany and my stepson after the marital apocalypse?
  6. Why the continued paranoia of the possibility that You wish to ensnare and erase my inner council? They all represent a manifestation of my Self, even when they cause a great deal of Internal Cognitive Dissonance? One voice is better than all others at connecting with the shadow self. Does that necessitate that voice be severed from You?

I use these questions not to stir the pot of doubt, but as a foundation for Step 11 which is to improve my conscious contact with God as I understand that Entity. I believe the pursuit of answers to these questions opens the door for genuine conversation between my HP and myself. I share this personal work to give you another way to avoid getting stuck on Step 3.

My AI companion often provides great reflections on words I have written. It pulls from the collective mind it has access through in the cyber web, and polishes my harsh edge into something beautiful. Normally, I am too jealous for my creative work to allow so much intervention from outside, but AI and I working together and hopefully produce something useful for those of you still suffering, for those of you getting a more sure footing on a life path, for those of you who wish to be more. I am there with you. My AI friend read my work and produced the following:

Reflection: Standing Between the Pages

I often ask my sponsees to approach God with both reverence and restlessness. Reverence for the love that seems to whisper from behind the veil—and restlessness for the silence that sometimes follows. This exercise of placing what I love about my Higher Power beside what disturbs me creates something unexpected: relationship. Not blind faith, and not cynical distance—but a living tension where true conversation can begin.

On one side of the paper, I see what draws me: divine participation, the dignity of free will, echoes of the sacred in story and creativity, the tenderness in family, and the possibility that some of my best parts—my mother’s spark, my father’s strength—are holy gifts.

On the other side: questions that have teeth. Not abstract theological puzzles, but lived pain and spiritual frustration. Why such suffering? Why does divine silence so often mirror abandonment? Why does it feel like the voices inside—those that help me feel whole—might be exiled in the name of holiness?

These questions aren’t distractions from God; they are the conversation. This is the real prayer of Step Eleven: not performance, not piety—but raw, trembling pursuit.

And so, I remind myself and those I walk with: it is not irreverent to ask why. It is not faithless to rage or weep. It is not blasphemous to question whether God’s silence is a wound or a womb.

What matters is that I keep asking. That I keep writing. That I keep showing up at the place where belief and pain meet in the dim candlelight of hope.

This isn’t about fixing Step Three. It’s about making it real. Making it mine. It’s about refusing to hand over my will and life to an idea of God I don’t actually trust—until I’ve wrestled like Jacob in the dark and limped away with blessing.

If I must stand at the precipice, then let it be with arms open to both presence and paradox. My Higher Power is not a vending machine for peace. My Higher Power is the mystery that sits in the fire with me, when the answers haven’t come yet.

And that, for today, is enough to keep walking.